Summary
- The SEC’s new rules are limiting shareholder resolutions, reducing investor influence
- Investors resorting to lawsuits, citing fiduciary duty concerns
- Policy shifts in U.S. unlikely to disrupt investment flows in Europe, Asia and the Pacific
- EU Omnibus package on sustainability reporting aligning with U.S. deregulation
- State-level energy policies in U.S. continue to support clean energy
The targets of US Administration’s attacks are many and various, but one area to which he has been consistently hostile is ESG, the environmental, social and governance risks that have become increasingly important to investors in recent years.
The new administration has attacked diversity and inclusion in all its forms, as well as withdrawn the U.S. from the Paris Agreement – again – and hollowed out USAID funding, a move that will affect climate projects around the world.
Last week, the new chief of the Environmental Protection Agency, Lee Zeldin, announced he had clawed back $20 billion in funding for clean energy and transportation from the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund.
These head-spinning changes are creating challenges for investors at a time when climate change and other ESG issues are more urgent than ever. “It is undeniable that Trump is bringing climate denial rhetoric into the mainstream,” says Dr Nina Seega, director of the Centre for Sustainable Finance at the Cambridge Institute for Sustainability Leadership (CISL).
“It’s deeply unhelpful given that we are seeing the impacts of climate change ramping up – such as the recent LA wildfires. Markets are trying to understand how much of the pullback is rhetoric, and how much is going to feed through into hard-core financials,” Seega adds.
Wells Fargo, for example, has dropped altogether its target of being net-zero across its financed portfolios by 2050, while a number of the largest financial institutions have withdrawn from net zero alliances, including Bank of America, Morgan Stanley, Citigroup, JPMorgan and Goldman Sachs.
Many other investors and companies, however, continue to use ESG; they are simply changing the way they talk about these issues, says Kirsten Spalding, who leads the Investor Network of sustainable investing advocacy group Ceres. “I am hearing some shifts in the language that people are using. They are not talking about ESG factors or sustainable investing. If they are looking at climate and other sustainability issues such as water or human rights, they are really focused on risk, opportunities and profitability.
“They are continuing to do the work in the same robust ways – they are not backing away from net-zero targets, for example – because it is the only way to mitigate risk across their portfolios.”
Andrew Behar, CEO of responsible business advocacy group As You Sow, agrees. He says investors are united in seeing climate risk as investment risk and in the belief that diversity improves financial performance.
In an environment that is more uncertain than ever due to climate and environmental issues, geopolitical turbulence and trade wars, investors are increasingly demanding transparency and accountability from companies so they know what risks their portfolios face.
However, there has been a worrying change in direction at the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), under the Trump Administration that ESG investors will have to navigate.
For example, the SEC is making it easier for companies to challenge shareholder resolutions. “Investors have used that mechanism for 30 years to signal what matters most to them,” Spalding says.
The SEC has also demanded extended disclosures from large shareholders in companies that engage with management on ESG matters, while narrowing the scope of resolutions investors are allowed to introduce.
The new guidance “appears to reduce opportunities for investors to challenge practices at companies where shareholder rights are perceived to be disadvantaged or to request additional information on financially material sustainability matters,” according to Morningstar. “This will likely reduce the frequency with which institutional shareholders like asset managers and pension funds engage with companies.”
As a result, investors are looking at other ways to engage companies, including more direct meetings with company boards, and abstentions, or “no” votes on company directors.
Investors are also likely to resort more to the courts, says Behar. “There will be so many lawsuits related to fiduciary duty because companies are being forced to underperform. The Trump Administration has made misogyny and racism policy. They hate free markets. They are using government to manipulate markets.”
It is still not clear to what extent Trump will stop funding from the Inflation Reduction Act and the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, given that many of the projects these laws were funding are in Republican states.
Data centre growth to meet the surge in AI is also driving demand for clean energy sources, which are among the cheapest sources of energy in the U.S. and elsewhere.
Zoe Whitton, head of strategy and impact at consultancy Pollination believes the impact on ESG will be minimal outside the U.S. “Policy shifts in the U.S. are unlikely to disrupt investment flows in Europe, Asia and the Pacific, where the business case remains strong. Even in the U.S., renewables will continue to be the most cost-effective power source in many cases, though investment decisions may become more complex due to the anti-green agency from the new administration.”
She adds: “Sustainability commitments are embedded across governments and businesses globally. While some jurisdictions and companies may scale back or rebrand their commitments to reduce exposure to the Trump Administration, we expect countries, states and firms to be less vocal but not to lose sight of the financial and operational risks associated with climate change.”
Many U.S. investors are bemoaning the difference between the U.S. approach and that of Europe (including the UK), Spalding adds, but EU itself appears to have taken a step backward.
The recent publication of the EU Omnibus package, which aimed to simplify sustainability rules including the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) and the EU Taxonomy, has dismayed many observers.
The package, which excludes four out of five companies from having to report on sustainability issues and asks less of those that are left, implements many changes that the U.S. had asked for, points out Tsvetelina Kuzmanova, CISL’s Sustainable Finance Policy Lead, including removing the risk of liabilities and penalties for failing to comply with the regulations.
However, there are limits to Trump’s influence, says Professor Jean-Michel Gauthier, executive director of the energy and finance chair at HEC Paris business school, because responsibility for energy policy sits at state rather than federal level. “In Trump’s first term, many states and cities, as well as corporates, decided to royally ignore the message from the federal government” on climate change and clean energy, he adds.
Much of states’ activity is going unnoticed, partly because they are drawing less attention to it themselves; partly because the media is either actively supportive of the new administration or is wary of upsetting it. “They (Trump’s supporters) control the narrative. They control Meta, X and Fox and all the other networks are pretty cowed right now,” says Behar.
But there is a growing awareness globally not just of climate impacts on company and investment performance but also the competitive advantages of embracing the sustainability agenda.
“There is a new industrial transformation going on and it’s not an optional thing,” says CISL’s Seega. “The question is are we going to have some sort of managed transition or a hugely disruptive one?”
Source: reuters.com






